Compare · Insomniac

Keep a MacBook awake with the lid closed

Amphetamine is the gold standard for keeping a Mac awake, free, mature, endlessly configurable. But the closed-lid case is special: macOS clamshell sleep isn't prevented by ordinary power assertions unless a display, power and keyboard are attached. That one case is the reason Insomniac exists.

Amphetamine / caffeinateInsomniac
Keep Mac awake, lid openPerfect, the standard toolYes
Keep Mac awake, lid CLOSED, nothing attachedNeeds a separate companion/workaroundThe whole point: works out of the box
Thermal safety with the lid shutNot its concernLive thermal advice + auto-stop before it gets too hot
MaturityYears of refinement, huge feature set1.0, signed and notarised, one job
Scheduling, triggers, scriptingExtensiveNone, it does one thing
PriceFreeFree
Pick theirs if…

Pick Amphetamine for everything except the closed-lid case, it is more mature, more flexible, and free.

Pick ours if…

Pick Insomniac if the closed-lid case IS your case: a MacBook running in a bag, on a shelf, or as a tiny server, with a safety layer watching the temperature, because a closed lid restricts airflow.