Compare · Insomniac

Keep a MacBook awake with the lid closed

Amphetamine is the gold standard for keeping a Mac awake, free, mature, endlessly configurable. But the closed-lid case is special: macOS clamshell sleep isn't prevented by ordinary power assertions unless a display, power and keyboard are attached. That one case is the reason Insomniac exists.

Amphetamine / caffeinateInsomniac
Keep Mac awake, lid openPerfect, the standard toolYes
Keep Mac awake, lid CLOSED, nothing attachedNeeds a separate companion/workaroundThe whole point: works out of the box
Thermal safety with the lid shutNot its concernLive thermal advice + auto-stop before it gets too hot
MaturityYears of refinement, huge feature setBeta
Scheduling, triggers, scriptingExtensiveNone, it does one thing
PriceFreeFree
Pick theirs if…

Pick Amphetamine for everything except the closed-lid case, it is more mature, more flexible, and free.

Pick ours if…

Pick Insomniac if the closed-lid case IS your case: a MacBook running in a bag, on a shelf, or as a tiny server, with a safety layer watching the temperature, because a closed lid restricts airflow.